Governments have written the rules and signed the contracts, so whether or not carbon capture helps the world reach net zero by 2050 now depends on governance within the companies that carry the commitments. This is where finance professionals come into their own.
While delays in progress (see panel) are often blamed on cost and technology, the deeper problem is governance.
The test of a real commitment is whether it holds when the conditions that produced it change
It was argued more than a decade ago that the main obstacles to carbon capture were not technical but lay in fragmented regulation, unclear long-term liability, weak public engagement and unstable financial incentives. Evidence today suggests that this is still the case.
Layers of governance
Carbon-capture governance can be broken down into three layers:
- outer layer: regulation – the laws, permits and contracts that set out what must be done
- middle layer: trust – whether investors, regulators and communities believe the commitments will be kept
- inner layer: the organisation – its ability to turn a commitment into decisions, controls and reports that hold for decades.
Most of the attention goes to the outer and middle layers, but the inner layer matters most when conditions change. A permit, contract or capacity announcement records a commitment at one moment. After that, partners sell, customers withdraw, costs rise and timelines slip. Storage obligations do not move with them. They run for decades, whoever the shareholders are.
The test of a real commitment is whether it holds when the conditions that produced it change. An organisation performs well when its structure fits its strategy and its environment. But if circumstances change, the conditions no longer fit, and someone within each organisation has to keep revisiting the commitment as stakeholders leave, projects are re-scoped and costs move. This is the inner layer.
Introducing ESM
We call this inner layer environmental sustainability management (ESM). ESM covers the processes, governance arrangements and management practices through which an organisation coordinates its environmental responsibilities, builds them into routine decisions and aligns its operations with what regulators and stakeholders expect.
Put simply, ESM is how an organisation keeps a commitment in place when the conditions around it change.
Carbon capture is often treated as a project that sits outside the finance function
Our study will explore how ESM works in practice, through interviews with stakeholders across Malaysia’s energy industry, where the law is new and organisations are building these arrangements now. The aim is to develop a carbon capture, utilisation and storage governance framework built from their accounts.
Where finance fits
Much of the work that ESM describes is already familiar to accountants. Allocating responsibility, designing controls over data, modelling long-term obligations and reporting to boards are part of everyday finance work.
Yet carbon capture is often treated as an engineering project or a financing deal that sits outside the finance function. That overlooks a practical point: finance is one of the few functions that sees the commercial terms, the long-term obligations and the information that reaches the board in one place. This makes it well placed to test whether a commitment would survive a change.
Finance leaders need to understand the following key issues:
- If a partner sold its stake tomorrow, which of our carbon capture commitments would be left without an owner?
- Does our board see delivery against our net-zero commitment or only progress against the project plan?
- Have we modelled what our commitments would cost if the timeline slipped by five years?
- Would our commitments survive a change of chief executive, finance director or strategy?
- What evidence would persuade a sceptical investor that our commitment is real?
With the target year of 2050 being less than 25 years away, the outer layers of carbon capture governance are largely in place. What will decide whether the tonnes are captured and stored is the inner layer – whether the organisations that made the commitments can keep them when conditions change.
This is a governance question, and it belongs to our profession as much as to engineers and policymakers.
Row-back
The International Energy Agency estimates that the world needs to capture about one billion tonnes of CO₂ a year by 2030 and about six billion tonnes by 2050, to achieve net zero. In 2022, the world captured about 45 million tonnes. However, much of the world’s potential capture capacity of around 425 million tonnes a year has been pushed back towards 2035.
Some major oil and gas companies have stepped back from carbon capture in South-East Asia, while Europe cancelled 5.4 million tonnes a year of proposed capture capacity in 2025. Earlier this year, oil giant BP said it would sell part of its equity in two flagship UK projects, less than 18 months after taking them to financial close. In addition, UK energy regulator Ofgem has proposed removing two of its three planned capture projects.