Author

Adam Deller is a financial reporting specialist and lecturer

1
unit

CPD

Studying this article and answering the related questions can count towards your verifiable CPD if you are following the unit route to CPD, and the content is relevant to your learning and development needs. One hour of learning equates to one unit of CPD.
Multiple-choice questions

As part of teaching my final-year financial reporting class at the University of Liverpool, I interrupt the three-hour lecture to provide the students with the annual update on my rankings of US states.

When I married an American, I made a comment about seeing all 50 states, which she probably thought was a joke at the time, but 18 states in, including a less than romantic trip to Delaware, and she is not laughing now.

I have a ranking not only of all 18 states so far but also the best food eaten in each. There is quite a lot of judgment expressed when my students discover that the greatest food I’ve eaten so far is a tub of ice cream from a bar in Florida.

But, to business. The UK regulator, the Financial Reporting Council (FRC), provides its own annual ranking of things and, like any good accountant, produces a presentation of its results. Its annual review of corporate reporting may not have any pictures of me eating burgers but it does contain a top five of reporting issues. To arrive at this, they asked companies substantive questions about their reporting. In that sense, you could argue that the top five is, in truth, a financial reporting bottom five in terms of the reporting quality.

Here the the top misdemeanours.

Cashflow statements

Cashflow statements continue to be the main reason for companies making a prior-year restatement as a result of the FRC’s enquiries. It is one of only two items that have been in the top five every year for the past five years.

This is not only a UK issue – the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) added a project on cashflows to its workplan in 2026. The IASB is looking at potential ways to improve the requirements of IAS 7, Statement of Cash Flows, and an exposure draft is expected in the first half of 2027.

Most questions around financial instruments were directed at non-financial services entities

The most common issues identified in the presentation of cashflows relate to classification issues, followed by inconsistencies in amounts/descriptions in the cashflow statement and other information in the accounts.

With classification issues being high on the error list, preparers will need to ensure they are fully aware of the changes that will be made under IFRS 18, Presentation and Disclosure in Financial Statements, applicable for periods beginning on or after 1 January 2027.

Financial instruments

Financial instruments is the other ever-present item, appearing in the top five every year since 2021. While this led to the FRC again asking preparers a high number of questions about their reporting, it pointed out that a number of these could have been avoided by companies including more complete and specific disclosure of relevant accounting policies and financial risks.

Of the restatements required following the queries raised, two were in relation to incorrect offsetting of cash and overdrafts. A third situation identified was where the terms of a loan provided did not meet the criteria of involving solely payments of principal and interest, so the initial treatment of amortised cost was incorrect, and the item had to be restated as measured at fair value through profit or loss.

Perhaps the biggest shock is the dethronement of impairment

The FRC noted that the majority of questions it raised were directed at non-financial services entities and will be considered further in a thematic review in 2026/27, with a particular focus on hedge accounting, expected credit losses and debt factoring arrangements.

Impairment of assets

Perhaps the biggest shock is the dethronement of impairment, which has been the top issue for the past three years. The FRC noted that over the past two years none of its impairment queries has led to restatements. Unsurprisingly, most of the queries here related to unclear assumptions used on projections and discount rates, or on how goodwill was allocated to cash-generating units.

While there may be fewer factual errors noted than previously, it is hard to believe that the issue of impairment being recognised too little and too late does not still exist. As the IASB has pointed out in its own impairment project (see my earlier AB article ‘Business combinations project moves on’), it is not a problem that can be easily solved by standard-setting.

Other misdemeanours

Finishing off the top five were fair value measurement at number four, and revenue at number five. In both cases, the FRC noted things could have been improved with clearer disclosures.

It also noted that, while provisions did not feature in the top five, there were more restatements to financial statements following queries raised on this topic. There was no common theme to these restatements; one resulted from an omission, whereas another arose from recognising a provision for future operating costs, which is prohibited.

IFRS 18 may send APMs back up the error table

While clearly UK-focused, this kind of annual review provides useful insight into likely issues in financial reporting in general. Although alternative performance measures (APMs) did not make the top five, the introduction of requirements for management-defined performance measures under IFRS 18 may well put the spotlight back on APMs in the future. Conversely, it may be hoped that IFRS 18 could lead to cashflow reporting dropping down the table.

Oh, and for completeness, top of the latest Deller state rankings is California. West Virginia comes bottom, with the high point being my own rendition of Take Me Home, Country Roads as we entered the state.

Watch and learn

See Adam Deller’s videos on different aspects of financial reporting, including his recent ‘Coffee shop wars’

Advertisement