Nigerian corporate disclosures are going through a slow revolution as companies come to terms with reporting in line with new sustainability reporting standards.
Mandatory application of IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards S1 and S2 starts from 2028, but a number of companies have already applied their provisions in their annual reporting.
‘Adopting the standards is not a walk in the park’
Enough time has now elapsed for tough lessons to be drawn from the experience, according to Rodney Ndamba FCCA, founder of the Zimbabwe-based Institute for Sustainability Africa, a member of the advisory panel for the ACCA Sustainability Working Group Africa and also for ACCA’s Global Forum for Sustainability. ‘Adopting the standards is not a walk in the park,’ he says. ‘They demand a lot of expertise.’
Volunteers
While mandatory application of the standards will not apply until corporate reports are published in 2029, many companies have been using them on a voluntary basis.
Four companies – Access Bank, Fidelity Bank, Seplat Energy and telecoms giant MTN Nigeria – applied the standards in reports they published in 2024. That gang of four has since grown to more than 50, according to data published by Nigeria’s Financial Reporting Council (FRC) in July this year.
These early adopters’ experiences of reporting under IFRS S1 and S2 are likely to prove invaluable for companies that adopt in the mandatory phase. So what lessons can be gleaned from the adoption journey so far?
‘There is now a lot more data in sustainability reporting’
Away from storytelling
‘What stands out is the shift away from sustainability reporting being about storytelling,’ says Jonathan Ikeolumba FCCA, a senior lecturer in accounting and finance at the Pan-Atlantic University in Lagos State. ‘Sustainability reporting used to be about qualitative storytelling, with companies describing their impact on society and the environment, accompanied by lots of pictures. But as the IFRS sustainability standards are investor-focused, there is now a lot more data in sustainability reporting, with actions being linked to financial impacts.’
‘Before the emergence of IFRS S1 and S2, companies tended to approach sustainability from a corporate social responsibility perspective,’ says Innocent Okwuosa, CEO of Entop Consulting and founder of the Nigerian Integrated Reporting Committee. ‘Now they have had to move in a new content direction. IFRS S1 and S2 require information on governance, strategy, risk management, and metrics and targets. If your sustainability report is not showing this content, then you are not complying with the standards.’
Yet the transition from corporate storytelling to investor-focused reporting that incorporates quantitative financial measurements has not necessarily been easy for Nigerian companies, according to Ndamba. This is largely due to measurements and valuations being complex, subjective processes.
‘The team will need to adopt new tech and collaborate with other functions’
Another reason, he adds, is that many companies have been reluctant to abandon impact-based reporting that uses the standards of the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) for fear of pushback from non-investor stakeholders. As a result, they have effectively adopted a hybrid reporting model that combines both the GRI standards and IFRS S1 and S2, which means having to balance the materiality requirements of both frameworks. GRI supports the concept of impact materiality (how a company impacts society and the environment) while S1 and S2 are based on financial materiality. Companies may not want to disclose certain information in one reporting format in case it conflicts with the other.
Given these challenges, it is not surprising that early and voluntary adopters of the IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards have made use of transitional reliefs. These include not having to report on Scope 3 emissions and being able to do qualitative rather than quantitative scenario analysis when they first report under IFRS S2.
Skills and data
‘Companies are still building the skillsets and competence to undertake quantitative scenario analysis that takes into account different climate scenarios and the implications for financial performance,’ Ikeolumba explains.
Gathering appropriate data to inform their sustainability reporting has been a further obstacle for adopters of IFRS S1 and S2. Many have chosen not to report on Scope 3 emissions due to the challenges involved with sourcing information from their customers and suppliers. Yet they have still struggled to gather data on their Scope 1 emissions (direct emissions from sources they own or control) and Scope 2 emissions (indirect emissions caused by their consumption of purchased energy).
‘SI and S2 are also about a change in business behaviour’
Ikeolumba argues that while the relevant data exists, it is often fragmented and held in silos within organisations. To aggregate that data, the team preparing the sustainability reporting will need to adopt new tech tools and collaborate with other functions. Accordingly, Ikeolumba advises companies preparing to adopt IFRS S1 and S2 in the mandatory phase to connect their sustainability team with other key functions including finance, procurement and operations to gain a holistic understanding of all the data points they will later need to report on.
Bridging the governance gap
Both IFRS S1 and S2 require companies to disclose on the governance processes they use to monitor and manage sustainability-related risks and opportunities. Historically, board sustainability committees have not been common in Nigeria, so companies have had to decide whether to create one or expand the role of existing committees, such as the risk committee, to cover sustainability. Furthermore, the standards require remuneration to be linked to sustainability performance. ‘There needs to be clarity, at a very detailed level, in terms of the sustainability performance targets that board directors should be appraised against,’ Ikeolumba says.
A lack of robust controls over sustainability reporting is one of the biggest governance gaps at present, according to Ndamba. For this reason, it is important that Nigerian boards focus on designing the internal control framework around sustainability reporting, to be sure that sustainability data is effectively validated and managed.
‘If it doesn’t attract capital, there could be significant implications’
As the board sets the tone at the top, it plays a pivotal role in promoting not only the adoption of IFRS S1 and S2 but embedding sustainable business practices throughout the organisation. ‘S1 and S2 are not just about regulatory compliance,’ Okwuosa says. ‘They are also about a change in business behaviour. Sustainability practices should lead to a change in business behaviour.’
Test case
Okwuosa believes that Nigeria is a good test case for other African nations preparing to adopt S1 and S2. This is a result of its strong regulatory leadership, including the clear roadmap for adoption set out by the Nigerian FRC, as well as collaborative efforts to raise board awareness and build capacity. For example, the Nigerian Integrated Reporting Committee has supported the FRC in implementing the standards by engaging with directors and building capacity through training.
Nigerian companies have made significant progress with adopting S1 and S2, in Ndamba’s view, but proof of success will depend on what happens next. ‘Will the standards enable Nigerian companies to attract much needed investment and capital?’ he asks. ‘If that is not proven, there could be quite significant implications, both for the standards and the country itself.’